The Bombay High Court has overturned a 1991 order upholding the classification of two land parcels in Saki Naka as slum areas, observing that the properties “has not been treated as slum for the last about 34 years”.
A single-judge bench of Justice MM Sathaye ruled that the slum notification should be withdrawn as the deficiencies that initially led to the classification had subsequently been addressed by the landowners.
The two plots, measuring 2,080 sq. metres and 933 sq. metres, respectively, accommodate tenants living in six chawls. The properties were declared slum areas through a government gazette notification in 1989 due to inadequate toilets, poor sanitation and insufficient basic facilities. The decision was subsequently upheld by the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvements, Clearance and Redevelopment) Tribunal in 1991.
In their petition, the wife and two sons of late property owner Manohar Magdum argued that the classification was based primarily on deficiencies in toilet facilities, pending repairs and inadequate water supply. They maintained that the required improvements had been completed following the High Court’s directions.
When the court admitted the petition in March 1992, it granted an interim stay on the slum notification and instructed the petitioners to repair eight existing toilets, improve the drainage system and construct two additional toilets. In October 1993, the family informed the court that the additional toilets had been built and living conditions improved.
During an inspection on May 5, 1989, the collector had found eight toilets damaged, nine clogged, overflowing septic tanks and gutters, and inadequate water supply. The authorities had initially provided two months for improvements.
However, the petitioners subsequently initiated eviction proceedings against 144 tenants, prompting the appointment of a commissioner to inspect the premises. The inspection report also highlighted inadequate sanitation facilities and water supply.
Court Finds No Further Action Under Slum Act
During the final hearing in August, the petitioners submitted that all necessary repairs had been completed and that the 75 existing tenant households had individual toilets.
The court also observed that neither the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA), established in 1995, nor the Deputy Collector (Encroachments) had initiated further proceedings concerning the properties after the interim stay was granted in 1992.
Noting that the improvements had been undertaken years earlier and no subsequent action had been initiated under the Slum Act, Justice Sathaye quashed the notification declaring the two plots as slum areas.
Source: Hindustan Times



