In Mumbai's luxury housing towers, even the space outside your front door can become a real estate opportunity. The only catch? It may not belong to you.
The distinction between private property and common property, it seems, is becoming increasingly negotiable—at least in the imagination of some homeowners.
The controversy surrounding Rustomjee Crown in Prabhadevi offers a striking illustration. In August 2026, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) initiated demolition action against unauthorised alterations in the luxury residential complex. The civic body had issued notices to flat owners over alleged encroachments involving common lobbies, kitchen ducts and ventilation shafts being incorporated into private apartments.
According to allegations raised by an activist, some owners had enclosed approximately 450–500 sq ft of common space. At prevailing market estimates cited in the complaint, this could represent an additional notional value of ₹2.25–2.5 crore per flat. These figures remain allegations, not established valuations.
The matter subsequently took a legal turn. Around 140 flat owners approached the Bombay High Court, alleging misrepresentation and seeking damages from the developer. The developer denied wrongdoing, maintaining that the project complied with sanctioned plans. In September 2026, the High Court stayed further BMC action against the affected spaces pending further proceedings.
The dispute raises a question much bigger than one residential complex: where does a homeowner's right to private property end, and the collective rights of other residents begin?
A lobby is not merely an inconvenient patch of flooring outside an apartment. It serves as circulation space, provides access to lifts and staircases, and forms part of the building's approved layout. Kitchen ducts and ventilation shafts, meanwhile, serve essential functions that cannot simply be absorbed into someone's interior design ambitions.
Yet Mumbai's property culture has developed an interesting relationship with space. Balconies become extensions, passages acquire partitions, parking spaces become personal storage units, and common terraces occasionally begin to resemble private lounges. Every additional inch is celebrated as a lifestyle upgrade, until someone asks whether it was legally available in the first place.
The problem is not limited to aesthetics. Unauthorised alterations can affect fire safety, ventilation, building compliance and the rights of fellow residents. They can also create complications when societies seek approvals, undertake repairs or consider future redevelopment.
For developers, too, the episode underlines the importance of clarity in marketing material, sanctioned plans and registered agreements. Buyers must know precisely what they are purchasing, what is exclusively theirs and what merely comes with shared access or usage rights.
And housing societies cannot afford to treat common areas as administrative leftovers. Their management committees must protect these spaces rather than wait for disputes to escalate into civic notices and court proceedings.
Mumbai's real estate market is constantly searching for ways to create more value from limited land. That ambition is understandable. But there is a difference between making better use of space and quietly taking over space that belongs to everyone.
Perhaps the next luxury amenity developers should advertise is not a private lift, an infinity pool or a landscaped podium, but something considerably less glamorous: a building where the common areas actually remain common.
After all, in a city where every square foot comes at a premium, the one thing residents should not have to pay extra for is the right to use the space that was always meant to be shared.
Mumbai may soon run out of land, but it appears to have an unlimited supply of adjectives. A modest redevelopment project can…
Learn moreMumbai has found a remarkably efficient way of making space. Demolish something old. Build something new. Put up a glossy hoarding. Call…
Learn moreMumbai has turned the square foot into the most important character in its real estate story. In most cities, a home is…
Learn moreMumbai has perfected the art of making a small home sound enormous. Its real estate market has developed a fascinating relationship with…
Learn more