Thane’s ambitious cluster redevelopment programme, covering nearly 50 projects across approximately 4,000 acres, has triggered concerns among urban planners and environmentalists over the pressure it could place on the city’s already strained civic infrastructure.
The Thane Municipal Corporation (TMC) and the Maharashtra government are proceeding with the initiative, which permits a Floor Space Index (FSI) of up to 12 for selected projects. Experts fear that the higher development potential could significantly increase population density without adequate improvements to essential services.
Thane’s population density, currently estimated at around 17,000 people per square kilometre, is projected to exceed 30,000 by 2046. However, concerns remain over the capacity of existing water supply networks, roads, sewage systems, schools and healthcare facilities to accommodate this growth.
Sulakshana Mahajan, who was part of the think tank behind the 2009 report recommending cluster redevelopment in Mumbai, described the permitted FSI as excessive.
“The enhanced FSI of 12 is unprecedented. The resulting scenario will result in structures that will be worse than vertical slums constructed by SRA,” she said.
Mahajan added that the group had recommended an FSI of 2–3 for densely populated areas of Mumbai. She also cautioned against comparing Thane with developed international cities without considering their supporting infrastructure.
“Cities in developed countries do have higher FSI. But these cities have world-class infrastructure. We cannot say the same about Thane,” she said.
Environmentalist Rohit Joshi also questioned the approach, stating, “The very objective of decongesting is defeated with the projects getting FSI up to 12, as the cluster sites are located in congested areas.”
The programme was launched in June 2023 under then Chief Minister Eknath Shinde, initially covering 45 projects across 3,700 acres. The scope has since expanded to around 50 projects covering nearly 4,000 acres.
NCP-SP Thane president Manoj Pradhan highlighted the city’s existing water shortage of 30 MLD and lack of an independent water source.
Political opposition intensified on August 27, when activists led by MLA Jitendra Awhad and Pradhan protested outside the TCDAICL office near Teen Hath Naka. Municipal Commissioner Saurabh Rao did not respond to messages seeking his comments.
Source: Mumbai Mirror



